Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Milk" scores more awards and noms, makes several top ten lists

Awards season is fully upon us, with major film critics, societies and foundations naming their favorite films and performances of 2008 and singling out recipients of various awards and special mentions.

Unsurprisingly, Gus Van Sant's Harvey Milk biopic, Milk, has been popping up all over the place thanks to its strong script and performances and philanthropic message of hope and equality for all. This week the Producers Guild of America granted the film the Stanley Kramer Award, a recognition granted every year to a film that "dramatically illuminates provocative social issues". (Milk star Sean Penn's 2002 i am sam also received the award, as have Antoine Fisher, The Great Debaters, In America, and others.)

Many cinephiles consider the annual National Board of Review Awards to be the tickly-throated first symptom of a full-fledged awards fever, and on December 1 they named Milk among their top ten films of the year (giving the coveted top slot to the excellent Slumdog Millionaire). They also named Josh Brolin Best Supporting Actor for his performance as Milk's assassin, Dan White. Meanwhile, the Critics' Choice Awards have nominated Milk in every major category except for lead and supporting actress ... because ... well, there really are none.

"Who, me?"

Milk has also been popping up on Top Ten lists across the country.  The New Yorker's David Denby, Time's Richard Corliss, The Chicago Sun-Times' Roger Ebert, and The New York Post's Lou Lemenick all ranked Milk high in their annual top tens (or top twenty, in Ebert's case), most within the top five. And as previously reported, Gus Van Sant was granted a special award by the Gotham Independent Film Awards for his contributions to independent film and the film has been nominated for three Spirit Awards.

More to come, we're sure! The Golden Globe noms are announced Thursday morning, and we'll be here to let you know if Milk scores any nods (we're guessing it will).

Liz's picture

BBM all over again?

someone told me they think Milk will be like Brokeback Mountain all over again.

tons of great reviews, it'll get awards...then come oscar time, NADA

 

 

 

 

Guillermo Serritiello's picture

2009 Spirit Awards overlooked both Milk and Van Sant

which I am quite surprised about as Milk to me is head and shoulders above Jonathan Demme's Rachel Getting Married, which (unlike Milk) got nods for Best Feature and Best Director. I am not a fan of any awards shows anymore, but recognize that nominations and wins help films that need a push.

I think that Milk is one of those needing a push as even with all the great reviews, the film still came in at number 11 this weekend. While it at least matched what it earned in its premiere weekend, it was being shown at least twice as many screens as it was during the first weeek. Milk still amassed an amazing average per screen, which was only approximated by the well-received Slumdog Millionaire and dwarfed by Frost/Nixon, which was only playing on 3 screens.

The good news is that all these best ofs showings and slow roll-out might lead to huge numbers in the long-run and would be a welcome change from movies that make all their money during the first 2 weekends and then its all about DVD sales/rentals. Maybe Milk can have both the financial success and the broad cultural impact by sticking around well into the new year. Go watch this movie and tell two others and so on.... I don't think that you'll be disappointed.

Guillermo's Media Guillotine: Entertainment, journalism, politics, and popular culture.

http://springintoaction.typepad.com

Liz's picture

only select theatres?

Is Milk only playing in select theatres or will it eventually play....in every movie theatre?
Brian Juergens's picture

well, not EVERY theater...

It's currently in about 100 theaters and expands another 260 or so this weekend, if I'm not mistaken. The slow rollout approach isn't unusual for this kind of film, and hopefully if box office continues to be strong (per-screen averages have been really high) it will keep expanding over time.
gabriel oak's picture

Milk's Oscar Chances

I think Milk will win some awards at the Oscars but probably not Best Picture. I'd really like to see Sean Penn win and the screenplay recognized.

I think that it has gotten a great critical reception and anyone interested in seeing good films will make an effort to see it. As Penn gets more awards, I think people will want to see his performance.

As far as it only being no. 11 at the box office, it can't possibly compete with films in more than 2,000 theaters.

David Ehrenstein's picture

Just in from the L.A. Film Critics meet

Sean Penn won Best Actor. Nothing else for Milk, however.